A bookshop is like a map of the world.
Pages and Co.: The Bookwanderers, Anna James, 2o19
I found it, y’all. I found my new Harry Potter.

Of course, somebody somewhere has labeled every middle grade fantasy series written in the past two decades “the new Harry Potter,” and often that seems like a stretch. Beyond looking at sales numbers, finding that new special series is going to be an individual thing. It’s about feeling.
And that feeling? That bubbly, happy sensation of encountering a fun story about a whimsical, alternate version of our reality in which magic exists? In which you wish you could just lose yourself forever? The same feeling that many people – not everyone, certainly, but lots of us – felt when reading the Harry Potter books for the first time? Reading The Bookwanderers was like that for me. I want to live in this book. Which probably explains why I loved it so much, considering that living in books is the whole point of this book.
the story
The novel follows Tilly Pages, a young girl who lives with her loving grandparents, who live next door to the family’s London bookshop, which sounds like the most wondrously cozy bookshop in the history of ever. (Did I mention I want to live in this book? I want to live in this book. Specifically in said bookshop, Pages & Co.)
Tilly has never known her father, and her mother mysteriously disappeared years ago under circumstances that her grandparents refuse to discuss. So, you know, the usual middle grade fantasy stuff. After Tilly tentatively befriends Oskar, the boy across the street, she notices characters from her favorite children’s books mysteriously appearing in the shop as she reads. She also discovers that she can travel into books with the characters – and she can bring Oskar with her. Eventually, her grandparents reveal that she comes from a long line of “bookwanderers:” essentially, people who read so intensely that they can magically travel into books (or pull characters out of books) while reading them. Tilly’s grandparents take the two children to the British Underlibrary, the large and magical library in charge of monitoring the practice of British bookwandering. Think the Ministry of Magic, except book magic. (The best kind of magic.) Turns out the Pages used to work at the Underlibrary before resigning under mysterious circumstances.
[FROM HERE THERE BE SPOILERS. YE HAVE BEEN WARNED.]
As Tilly and Oskar begin their bookwandering training by visiting various children’s books, they notice a sinister employee of the Underlibrary, Enoch Chalk, stalking them through their various book adventures. With good reason: Tilly turns out to have special bookwandering abilities because…wait for it…she’s half fictional! Her father was a character from a book, and for various reasons that I won’t spoil, Enoch also trapped Tilly’s mother in a copy of A Little Princess. It’s up to Tilly and Oskar to rescue Tilly’s mother and expose Enoch’s treachery.
the babble
Like I said, it’s as though Anna James sat down and thought, “Hmm, like the Harry Potter template…except BOOKS. And a secret society of magical librarians.” Which is 100% relevant to my interests and tastes, so I’m here for it.
This book will satisfy not only young readers, but older readers who enjoy YA books and want to relive their old classic favorites like Anne of Green Gables, Alice and Wonderland, and such through a new lens. One of the novel’s greatest pleasures is watching James capture the feeling of those earlier classics to create brand-new scenes involving our protagonists while they bookwander. So The Bookwanderers is a treat for bibliophiles…and for Anglophiles, too. It is unapologetically BRITISH, like many of the classics it attempts to evoke. (Aside from Oskar and his mum, diversity doesn’t seem to be a big priority for this series.) If that’s not your jam, you may not care for it.
The world building here is exquisite. I love the rules of bookwandering, I love the literalism of the British Underlibrary hovering underneath the British Library (*drool*), I love the varying philosophies on bookwandering and what it means and how to use it. Most of all, I love Pages & Co. itself. Can I please live there?
This isn’t a super deep novel, but not every novel needs to be. It’s deep in the sense that it addresses the sacred connection that many of us feel to certain books, as adults and certainly as children (and for many of us, as adults looking back to when we were children). It is charming, witty, and fast-paced, and it leaves you with a warm glow in your chest. It’s going on my cheer-me-up shelf.
rating
***1/2 out of 4
random babble
- Did I mention that Pages & Co is multiple stories tall and contains a tea/coffee shop, and that Jack, who seems to be the only employee, sounds delightful? And that it’s in London? Gah.
- Of all the classic characters James brings in, I think she captures Anne the best, but your mileage may vary.
- I love Enoch Chalk’s motivation. The discussion of forgotten books is so poignant.
- Okay, I know I haven’t written a review about this one yet, but has anyone else read this book and also The Starless Sea by Erin Morgenstern (if not, you need to) and noticed that they’re basically the same book in adult and children’s versions, and they came out at similar times? Even down to the important bee symbol. Spooky.





